Blog · The system
Power that stops at the provincial capital
The Constitution promises elected local governments with real powers. In practice they come and go at the pleasure of provincial governments. That has to end.
Article 140-A of the Constitution requires every province to set up a local government system by law and to hand political, administrative and financial authority to elected local representatives.[1] It does not say when elections must be held, how much money local governments receive, or what happens when a province simply lets them lapse. That gap is where Pakistan’s local democracy keeps falling through.
Rare agreement across the country
On this, the provinces themselves now agree. In October 2025 the Punjab Assembly unanimously asked the federal government to amend Article 140-A to protect local governments and make elections mandatory within 90 days of their dissolution.[2] In January 2026 the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Assembly unanimously asked for a separate constitutional chapter on local government, with real political, administrative and financial powers; the resolution was moved by the PPP’s parliamentary leader.[3] The MQM-P has made a 28th Amendment on Article 140-A its condition for supporting the government.[4] A former foreign secretary, writing in Dawn, set out the minimum: guaranteed elections, financial independence and legal protection.[5]
Even many opponents of new provinces agree. Dawn argues that the problem is excessive centralisation and that new provinces will not improve governance without empowered local governments.[6] That is a case for doing both, not for doing neither.
What a constitutional chapter on local government should say
Our proposals:
- Elections on a fixed clock. Local elections within 90 days of a council’s term ending, run by the Election Commission, with no power for a province to postpone them.
- Money that follows the mandate. Every province passes a Provincial Finance Commission award with a guaranteed minimum share for local councils, published each year.
- No dismissal by decree. A provincial government cannot suspend or dissolve an elected council except through a court or a fresh election.
- Mayors who answer to voters. Directly elected heads of city and district governments, with clear control of local services.
- First or alongside, never after. Local government protection should not wait for new provinces. It can pass now.
New provinces bring government closer. Local government brings it to the street. A reset needs both. See how they fit together in our plan.
The other side
What critics say
- The Pakistan Peoples Party has vowed to resist any change that would roll back the 18th Amendment’s devolution to the provinces, and warns against a 28th Amendment that does so.[7] Local government is a provincial subject, and some provinces see federal guarantees as interference.
- The Express Tribune welcomed more provinces if they are people-centric, but warned that without local bodies and fiscal fairness they risk becoming another weak layer.[8]
This post states Reset Pakistan’s opinion. Statements by others are summarised in our words and linked to the original reporting.
Sources
- Constitution of Pakistan, Article 140-A (Part IV, Chapter 3)
- The Express Tribune: Punjab seeks constitutional protection for local bodies
- The News, 15 Jan 2026: KP Assembly demands amendments to Constitution to protect LG system
- The News, 26 Mar 2026: MQM-P chief demands immediate introduction of 28th Amendment
- Dawn, 7 Jun 2026: op-ed on Article 140-A and the 28th Amendment
- Dawn, 15 Aug 2026: Governance test (editorial)
- The News, 14 May 2026: on the 28th Amendment and the 18th
- The Express Tribune, 13 Jan 2026: New provinces? (editorial)