Blog · The map
Four provinces cannot govern 242 million people
Pakistan has grown more than sevenfold since 1951. The number of its provinces has not changed. That is why a reset starts with the map.
Pakistan’s population has grown more than sevenfold since 1951.[2] The 2023 census counted 241.5 million people.[1] Punjab alone has 127.7 million, more than all but twelve countries in the world.[2] An average Pakistani province or territory governs about 49 million people. In Brazil, Indonesia, Nigeria and the United States the average state or province has fewer than 8 million.[3]
Size is not an abstraction. Hassan Baig, writing in The News, described what it means in practice: a six-hour drive from Rajanpur to Lahore to complete a government form.[4] Afzal Ali Shigri, a former police chief of Sindh, argues that four large provinces keep power with a few cities and a few families, and that smaller units would make room for new leaders.[5]
The argument has crossed party lines
What was once a fringe idea is now said aloud by ministers. Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi says new administrative units will have to be created.[6] Planning Minister Ahsan Iqbal has proposed 12 to 15 provinces.[7] Defence Minister Khawaja Asif backs as many as 12, provided they are drawn on administrative grounds and not on language, ethnicity or political interest.[8] The MQM-P wants a national dialogue,[9] and Bilawal Bhutto Zardari has pointed to consensus on a South Punjab province.[10] Reports this month describe a 12-province formula and a possible referendum.[11]
The public appears to be ahead of the politicians. A survey of 5,000 adults by Meridian Analytics found 77% support for more provinces, up from 54% in 2022. It is one survey, and a survey is not a referendum, but the direction is clear.[2]
Administrative lines, not ethnic ones
How new provinces are drawn matters as much as whether. Jamaat-e-Islami’s Hafiz Naeemur Rehman is not opposed to administrative units but warns against dividing people on ethnic lines.[12] We agree. Our plan builds 20 provinces entirely from existing divisions, so no district is split and no new boundary is invented. No unit would hold more than about one Pakistani in ten; today one province holds more than one in two. Read the full plan, with census tables and costs.
Distance counts as much as numbers
Population is only half the problem. Balochistan covers about two-fifths of Pakistan, and Gwadar is about 900 km and 13 hours by road from Quetta.[18] When France drew its departments in 1790, it set boundaries so that every settlement was within a day’s ride of the departmental capital.[19] Pakistan needs the modern version of that rule: no province much larger than about 100,000 km², close to the median for G20 countries. That is why our plan gives Balochistan four seats of government, with a compact that keeps its resources with all its people.
A bigger map is not a better government by itself. New provinces must come with real local government and a reformed civil service, which is why our next two posts are about the system and the service. But a country of 242 million cannot keep pretending that four provincial capitals are close enough to everyone.
The other side
What critics say
- PPP Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari says the debate must stop because the Sindh Assembly has already rejected dividing the province; Chief Minister Murad Ali Shah says no bloodshed will be allowed over it.[13][14]
- Baloch parties reject new provinces, alleging the real aim is control of Balochistan’s natural resources.[15]
- Dawn argues the problem is excessive centralisation, not too few provinces, and that new provinces will not help without empowered local governments.[16] PILDAT’s Ahmed Bilal Mehboob makes the same case for local government as the faster, cheaper route.[17]
This post states Reset Pakistan’s opinion. Statements by others are summarised in our words and linked to the original reporting.
Sources
- PBS, 7th Population and Housing Census 2023
- Pakistan Observer: Provinces by vote, not veto
- UN World Population Prospects 2024 (our calculation of people per unit)
- The News, 1 Sep 2026: Hassan Baig, New provinces won't be enough
- Dawn, 24 Apr 2026: Afzal Ali Shigri, A case for smaller provinces
- The Friday Times, 16 Oct 2026: New provinces debate
- The News, 4 Sep 2026: Ahsan Iqbal proposes 12 to 15 new provinces
- The Express Tribune, 9 Nov 2026: PML-N's Asif backs twelve new provinces
- ARY News, 16 Aug 2026: MQM-P calls for national dialogue on new provinces
- Aaj News, 7 Aug 2026: Bilawal on consent and South Punjab
- The News, 8 Nov 2026: Creation of 12 provinces, referendum may precede 28th Amendment
- ARY News, 18 Aug 2026: Hafiz Naeem on new provinces
- The Express Tribune, 28 Oct 2026: Bilawal calls for end to new provinces debate
- The Express Tribune, 6 Aug 2026: Sindh CM on new provinces
- The Express Tribune, 22 Aug 2026: Baloch leaders reject new provinces proposal
- Dawn, 15 Aug 2026: Governance test (editorial)
- Dawn, 23 Aug 2025: Ahmed Bilal Mehboob
- Rome2rio: Quetta to Gwadar by road
- Wikipedia, Departments of France