Debate board · Statements

Who said what, with the source

Statements for, against and in between on three questions of the reset. Each summary is ours and links to the original report. A colour describes one statement on one question, not the person.

  • Provinces: Should Pakistan create new provinces or administrative units?
  • Local government: Should local governments get constitutional protection (Article 140-A)?
  • Civil service: Should the civil service be overhauled?

Red LineQuestion: Provinces

Said Pakistan's economy cannot bear the cost of extra assemblies, secretariats, chief minister and governor houses and courts, asking whether a province is like a new housing society.

Syed Nasir Hussain ShahSindh Local Government Minister, PPP
Grey ZoneQuestion: Provinces

Said Article 239 is the only valid route and a referendum cannot replace it, and argued new provinces alone would not make government work better.

Abdul Moiz JaferiiConstitutional lawyer, Karachi
Grey ZoneQuestion: Provinces

Called a referendum a legitimate route that elected representatives cannot ignore, and said the party leadership will decide the PML-N's position.

Malik Ahmad KhanSpeaker, Punjab Assembly (PML-N)
Green LightQuestion: Provinces

Said a referendum will decide whether new provinces are created, called December a crucial month, and argued that power has been concentrated in the chief minister's house.

Syed Mustafa KamalFederal Health Minister, MQM-P
Green LightQuestion: Provinces

Reportedly endorsed new provinces as being in the national interest, according to party sources cited by ARY News after a meeting with his lawyers.

Imran KhanFounder, Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (as reported)
Green LightQuestion: Provinces

Backed as many as 12 provinces, provided they are created on administrative grounds and not on language, ethnicity or political interest.

Khawaja AsifFederal Defence Minister
Green LightQuestion: Provinces

Said the 28th Amendment is expected before the year ends, and that if new provinces are not created through it, they never will be.

Huzaifa RehmanSpecial Assistant to the Prime Minister
Grey ZoneQuestion: Provinces

Estimated each new province's core institutions at Rs 22.4-25.9bn a year and all 30 divisions as provinces at Rs 609-730bn; urged formal costing and a 10% screen, and suggested local governments where the goal is access to services.

PRIME (Policy Research Institute of Market Economy)Think tank, Islamabad
Red LineQuestion: Provinces

Said the debate on new administrative units must stop, because the Sindh Assembly has already given its verdict against dividing the province.

Bilawal Bhutto ZardariChairman, Pakistan Peoples Party
Red LineQuestion: Provinces

Said at a BNP event in Karachi that they would not accept any decision on new provinces, and that national issues must be settled by dialogue, not force.

Opposition leadersSardar Akhtar Mengal, Mahmood Khan Achakzai, Allama Raja Nasir Abbas, Asad Qaiser and others
Grey ZoneQuestion: Provinces

Said only Parliament can decide whether provinces are created, and that the PML-N will state its policy when the matter comes before it.

Rana SanaullahAdviser to the Prime Minister on Political Affairs
Red LineQuestion: Provinces

Argued that Pakistan does not need more governments but more devolution, because only devolution changes who actually holds power.

The Friday TimesOpinion
Grey ZoneQuestion: Provinces

Said his party is not against new units in principle, but timing and circumstances matter and no decision should be imposed without political debate.

Maulana Fazlur RehmanChief, Jamiat Ulema-e-Islam (F)
Grey ZoneQuestion: Provinces

Urged political forces not to decide on new provinces in haste or without broad public consensus.

Barrister Gohar Ali KhanChairman, Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf
Green LightQuestion: Provinces

Told the National Policy Dialogue in Lahore that new administrative units will have to be created, and that a decision of this scale should follow public sentiment.

Mohsin NaqviFederal Interior Minister
Red LineQuestion: Provinces

Said the PPP will not accept any move to change Sindh's status, and warned federal ministers against interfering in provinces' constitutional status.

Nisar KhuhroPresident, PPP Sindh
Red LineQuestion: Provinces

Rejected the government's reported plan for 15 provinces as a wrong decision, saying two provinces are burning while the government talks of new ones.

Maulana Fazlur RehmanChief, Jamiat Ulema-e-Islam (F)
Green LightQuestion: Provinces

Proposed 12 to 15 provinces by dividing each existing province into three, and asked the Prime Minister to form a committee to start a national debate.

Ahsan IqbalFederal Minister for Planning, Development & Special Initiatives
Green LightQuestion: Civil service

Found the civil service model rooted in a colonial legacy and last modified in 1973, and finalised recommendations to overhaul it.

Committee on Civil Service ReformsFederal government committee
Grey ZoneQuestion: Provinces

Agreed the distance problem is real, citing six-hour drives to Lahore for a government form, but argued new provinces will not decentralise power on their own.

The NewsOpinion
Red LineQuestion: Provinces

Rejected proposals for new provinces on administrative grounds, alleging the real aim is control over Balochistan's natural resources.

Balochistan political partiesANP, National Party, BNP, JUI, PkMAP and others, Quetta
Red LineQuestion: Provinces

Argued that a new map does not by itself produce a more competent state, and that devolution matters more than division.

Mohsin Saleem UllahLawyer (op-ed)
Grey ZoneQuestion: Provinces

Said Jamaat-e-Islami is not opposed to administrative units but they must follow the Constitution, and warned against using the issue to divide people on ethnic lines.

Hafiz Naeemur RehmanEmir, Jamaat-e-Islami Pakistan
Green LightQuestion: Provinces

Called on all parties to start a national dialogue on new provinces across the country, saying the case is strongest in Sindh.

Dr Khalid Maqbool SiddiquiChairman, MQM-P
Red LineQuestion: Provinces

Vowed to resist new provinces, saying that in present circumstances they would complicate Pakistan's problems rather than solve them.

Dr Abdul Malik BalochPresident, National Party
Red LineQuestion: Provinces

Argued Pakistan's problem is excessive centralisation, not too few provinces, and that new provinces will not improve governance without empowered local governments.

DawnEditorial
Green LightQuestion: Provinces

Backed smaller provinces and new administrative units to bring political and financial powers, resources and public services closer to citizens.

Jam Kamal KhanFederal Commerce Minister
Grey ZoneQuestion: Provinces

Said provinces should be created with public consent and political consensus, citing consensus on a South Punjab province.

Bilawal Bhutto ZardariChairman, Pakistan Peoples Party
Grey ZoneQuestion: Provinces

Said the Constitution has no express provision for creating new provinces, so it should first be amended to add one.

Waqar RanaFormer Additional Attorney General
Red LineQuestion: Provinces

Said the Sindh Assembly has repeatedly and unanimously opposed any new province in Sindh, and that no bloodshed would be allowed over the issue.

Syed Murad Ali ShahChief Minister, Sindh
Green LightQuestion: Provinces

Renewed the demand for a Hazara province, saying population growth and administrative needs have made new provinces inevitable.

Sardar Muhammad YousafFederal Minister for Religious Affairs
Grey ZoneQuestion: Provinces

Called for a national debate on whether new provinces are needed and what they would deliver, with free and fair elections first.

Mustafa Nawaz KhokharFormer Senator
Grey ZoneQuestion: Provinces

Said new provinces alone cannot fix governance and that sweeping bureaucratic reform must come first.

Barrister Aqeel MalikMinister of State for Law and Justice
Green LightQuestion: Civil service

Said sweeping reform of the bureaucracy has become an urgent requirement and must precede any new provinces.

Barrister Aqeel MalikMinister of State for Law and Justice
Green LightQuestion: Provinces

Called new administrative provinces the key to strengthening democracy, reviving the economy and delivering effective governance.

Abdul Aleem KhanPresident, Istehkam-e-Pakistan Party; Federal Communications Minister
Grey ZoneQuestion: Civil service

Argued that decades of reform announcements, portals and e-governance slogans have been mostly optics, without real change in recruitment and accountability.

Dr Syed Akhtar Ali ShahFormer Home Secretary, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, and retired IG (op-ed)
Green LightQuestion: Provinces

Demanded a separate South Punjab province in the Senate, saying that when a province grows too large its division becomes necessary.

Rana Mahmoodul HassanSenator, Pakistan Peoples Party
Green LightQuestion: Local government

Urged that the 28th Amendment strengthen Article 140-A with guaranteed elections, financial independence and legal protection for local bodies.

Former foreign secretaryChairman, Sanober Institute (op-ed)
Green LightQuestion: Civil service

Replaced a 62-year-old code of conduct with new rules on asset declarations, conflicts of interest and social media use.

Federal governmentCivil Servants (Conduct) Rules 2026
Grey ZoneQuestion: Local government

Has vowed to resist any change to the 18th Amendment's devolution to the provinces, warning the government against a 28th Amendment that rolls it back.

Pakistan Peoples PartyParty position, as reported
Green LightQuestion: Provinces

Argued that four large provinces concentrate power in a few cities and dynasties, and that smaller units drawn on administrative and economic lines would open space for new leaders.

Afzal Ali ShigriFormer Inspector General of Police, Sindh (op-ed)
Green LightQuestion: Local government

Demanded the immediate introduction of the 28th Amendment to implement Article 140-A, calling it the party's sole condition for supporting the government.

Dr Khalid Maqbool SiddiquiChairman, MQM-P
Green LightQuestion: Civil service

Ordered a performance-based evaluation system for federal secretaries to align the bureaucracy with international standards.

Shehbaz SharifPrime Minister
Green LightQuestion: Local government

Unanimously passed a resolution, moved by the PPP's parliamentary leader, seeking a constitutional chapter on local government and real political, administrative and financial powers for it.

Khyber Pakhtunkhwa AssemblyUnanimous resolution
Grey ZoneQuestion: Provinces

Called more provinces a welcome change if they are people-centric, but warned that without local bodies and fiscal fairness they risk becoming another weak layer.

The Express TribuneEditorial
Red LineQuestion: Provinces

ANP's central council, under his chairmanship, rejected the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Assembly's resolution for a Hazara province.

Aimal Wali KhanPresident, Awami National Party
Green LightQuestion: Local government

Unanimously asked the federal government to amend Article 140-A to protect local governments and make elections mandatory within 90 days of dissolution.

Punjab AssemblyUnanimous resolution
Green LightQuestion: Provinces

Argued that new provinces are at the heart of governance reform, not a distraction from it, provided they are implemented responsibly.

Hamna ObaidColumnist, Daily Times
Red LineQuestion: Provinces

Argued that empowered local governments, not new provinces, are the practical and cost-effective route to devolution.

Ahmed Bilal MehboobPresident, PILDAT (op-ed)
Grey ZoneQuestion: Civil service

Welcomed greater specialisation in the reform package but warned that a proposed new cadre could become another elite service, and said downsizing is essential.

DawnEditorial

Spotted an error, or a statement we should add? Write to ResetPakistan@protonmail.com and we will correct or add it with a dated note. Last checked 17 November 2026.

Public opinion

Public opinion

77%

of 5,000 adults backed creating new provinces in Meridian Analytics' National Barometer 2026, up 23 points since 2022. Support ran from 72% in Balochistan to 80% in Sindh, and 92% in Karachi. This is a single survey; its full methodology has not been independently reviewed. Minute Mirror, 13 Nov 2026 · Daily Pakistan

How the debate moved

  1. MQM-P says it will push for more provinces through a 28th Amendment. Dawn

  2. Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi calls for new provinces as part of governance reform; the debate restarts. The Express Tribune

  3. Planning Minister Ahsan Iqbal proposes 12 to 15 provinces. The News

  4. PPP Sindh and JUI-F reject a reported 15-province plan. The Express Tribune

  5. PPP Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari says the debate must stop. The Express Tribune

  6. PM's aide says a 28th Amendment is expected before the year ends. ARY News

  7. Reports: a 12-province plan with a nationwide referendum is under consideration. Minute Mirror

  8. PRIME estimates new provinces would cost Rs 22.4-25.9bn a year each to run, and up to Rs 730bn a year if every division became a province. The Standard

  9. Reports: the government speeds up groundwork for a referendum before the March 2027 Senate elections. ARY News

  10. Reports: a plan to give Islamabad special status under a mayor, and to add parts of Haripur, Rawalpindi and Murree (NA-51) to the capital. The Nation