Debate board · History and the world

Pakistan’s provinces since 1947, and what other countries did

Pakistan has had the same four provinces since 1970, while its population has grown several times over. Here is how the map and the devolution debate got here, and how five other countries changed their units as their economies grew.

From 1947 to today

  1. Pakistan begins with East Bengal, West Punjab, Sindh, the North-West Frontier Province and Baluchistan, alongside princely states such as Bahawalpur.

    Wikipedia: Divisions of Pakistan

  2. Prime Minister Mohammad Ali Bogra announces One Unit.

    Wikipedia: One Unit

  3. One Unit takes effect: West Pakistan’s provinces and tribal areas become a single province governed from Lahore. Bahawalpur state is merged into it the same day.

    Wikipedia: One Unit Wikipedia: Bahawalpur (princely state)

  4. General Yahya Khan dissolves One Unit by the Legal Framework Order; the western provinces are restored.

    Wikipedia: One Unit

  5. The Constitution’s Article 239(4) lets a province’s limits change only with two-thirds of its own assembly, as well as of Parliament.

    Dawn: the constitutional route for new provinces

  6. Musharraf’s Devolution Plan takes effect, creating elected district governments.

    Wikipedia: Local government in Pakistan

  7. The 18th Amendment is signed: it abolishes the Concurrent List, renames NWFP Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and, through Article 140-A, requires provinces to devolve power to elected local governments.

    Wikipedia: Eighteenth Amendment Dawn, 18 Jun 2026: ANP white paper on 16 years of the 18th Amendment The Express Tribune: MQM-P on Article 140-A

  8. The Punjab Assembly unanimously passes resolutions for Bahawalpur and South Punjab provinces.

    Dawn, 10 May 2012: Assembly backs South Punjab, Bahawalpur provinces

  9. The Senate passes the 24th Amendment Bill for a Bahawalpur Janoobi Punjab province. It lapses for want of two-thirds in the National Assembly.

    Dawn, 6 Mar 2013: Senate passes 24th Amendment Bill Daily Times, 5 May 2019: PPP re-tables South Punjab bill

  10. The 25th Amendment merges the tribal areas (FATA and PATA) into Khyber Pakhtunkhwa.

    Wikipedia: Twenty-fifth Amendment

  11. PTI promises a South Punjab province within 100 days of taking office.

    Dawn, 2018: PTI's South Punjab promise and resolution

  12. PML-N tables a constitutional amendment for Bahawalpur and South Punjab provinces.

    Dawn, 29 Jan 2019: PML-N bill for Bahawalpur and South Punjab provinces

  13. Punjab creates 385 posts for a South Punjab Secretariat, without constitutional status.

    Dawn, 6 Jun 2020: 385 posts for south Punjab secretariat

  14. PML-N and MQM-P sign an accord to give local governments constitutional powers directly from the federation.

    Dawn, 2 Mar 2024: PML-N and MQM-P accord to empower local governments

  15. The Punjab Assembly unanimously asks for constitutional protection for local governments.

    The Express Tribune: Punjab seeks constitutional protection for local bodies

  16. The Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Assembly passes a resolution for a Hazara province; ANP rejects it.

    The Express Tribune, Jan 2026: ANP rejects Hazara province resolution

  17. A Sindh Assembly resolution against new provinces; MQM-P calls it an attack on the federation.

    Dawn, 23 Feb 2026: MQM-P terms PA resolution against new provinces an attack on federation

  18. Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi calls for new administrative units, reopening the national debate.

    The Express Tribune: Bilawal urges Naqvi to debate new provinces in Parliament

  19. The Sindh Assembly passes a unanimous resolution against dividing Sindh.

    The Express Tribune, 3 Sep 2026: Sindh Assembly unites against division of Sindh

  20. Reports say the government is preparing a referendum on 10 to 12 new provinces.

    ARY News, 14 Nov 2026: Govt speeds up groundwork for referendum on new provinces

Five countries that redrew their maps

India went from 14 states in 1956 to 28; Nigeria from 3 regions to 36 states; Indonesia from 11 provinces to 38; Bangladesh from 4 divisions to 8; Brazil from 20 states to 26. Pakistan went from four provinces to one and back to four.

Units and output, 1947 to 2022

Press play. Top: each country’s number of first-level units against its GDP, with a trail of where it has been. Bottom: the number of units over time.

PakistanIndiaBangladeshNigeriaBrazilIndonesia
Show the data
CountryFirst-level unitsGDP, billion int-$ (2011 prices)What is counted
1950196019701980199020002010202219501970199020102022
Pakistan41444444401002908051,319Provinces within today’s borders, to match the GDP series: One Unit merged the four western provinces into one, 1955–70.
India27151722252828283547491,7515,36110,476States, not union territories. 1950 counts Part A, B and C states; the 1956 reorganisation merged many of them.
Bangladesh———446783968112400858Divisions of a unitary state, counted from independence in 1971.
Nigeria—312192136363638971718101,134Regions until 1967, then states; the Federal Capital Territory is not counted.
Brazil20212222262626261194431,1852,8203,187States, not the Federal District or territories. Tocantins was created and two territories became states in 1988.
Indonesia11222627273033381062217192,0393,500Provinces. Counts before 1970 are approximate; East Timor is counted 1976–99.
GDP: Maddison Project Database 2023, at 2011 international-dollar prices, within today’s borders, via Our World in Data; between five-year points we interpolate. Units: as listed on Wikipedia; see “What is counted”. More units do not cause growth by themselves: these countries also changed policy, opened up and invested. The chart shows that adding units has not stopped any of them growing.

Sources

  1. Wikipedia: Divisions of Pakistan
  2. Wikipedia: One Unit
  3. Wikipedia: Bahawalpur (princely state)
  4. Dawn: the constitutional route for new provinces
  5. Wikipedia: Local government in Pakistan
  6. Wikipedia: Eighteenth Amendment
  7. Dawn, 18 Jun 2026: ANP white paper on 16 years of the 18th Amendment
  8. The Express Tribune: MQM-P on Article 140-A
  9. Dawn, 10 May 2012: Assembly backs South Punjab, Bahawalpur provinces
  10. Dawn, 6 Mar 2013: Senate passes 24th Amendment Bill
  11. Daily Times, 5 May 2019: PPP re-tables South Punjab bill
  12. Wikipedia: Twenty-fifth Amendment
  13. Dawn, 2018: PTI's South Punjab promise and resolution
  14. Dawn, 29 Jan 2019: PML-N bill for Bahawalpur and South Punjab provinces
  15. Dawn, 6 Jun 2020: 385 posts for south Punjab secretariat
  16. Dawn, 2 Mar 2024: PML-N and MQM-P accord to empower local governments
  17. The Express Tribune: Punjab seeks constitutional protection for local bodies
  18. The Express Tribune, Jan 2026: ANP rejects Hazara province resolution
  19. Dawn, 23 Feb 2026: MQM-P terms PA resolution against new provinces an attack on federation
  20. The Express Tribune: Bilawal urges Naqvi to debate new provinces in Parliament
  21. The Express Tribune, 3 Sep 2026: Sindh Assembly unites against division of Sindh
  22. ARY News, 14 Nov 2026: Govt speeds up groundwork for referendum on new provinces
  23. Maddison Project Database 2023, GDP at 2011 international-$ prices, via Our World in Data
  24. Wikipedia: States and union territories of India
  25. Wikipedia: States of Nigeria
  26. Wikipedia: States of Brazil
  27. Wikipedia: Provinces of Indonesia
  28. Wikipedia: Divisions of Bangladesh
  29. Wikipedia: One Unit