Blog · The service

A 1973 machine for a 2026 country

The government’s own reform committee says the civil service still runs on a colonial design. New provinces without a new service would only copy the old one.

In September 2026 the federal Committee on Civil Service Reforms reached a blunt conclusion: Pakistan’s civil service model is rooted in a colonial legacy and was last substantially modified in 1973. The committee says it has finalised recommendations for an overhaul.[1] It is rare for a government to say this about itself. It should be taken at its word.

Small steps in the right direction

Some changes are already under way. In January the Prime Minister ordered a performance-based evaluation system for federal secretaries.[2] In May the government replaced a 62-year-old code of conduct with new rules on asset declarations, conflicts of interest and social media.[3] The Minister of State for Law, Barrister Aqeel Malik, has gone further, saying sweeping reform of the bureaucracy must come before any new provinces.[4]

What a real reset of the service would mean

These are our proposals, offered for debate:

  • Published service standards. Every department states what a citizen gets, how fast and at what cost, and reports against it each quarter.
  • Performance contracts with consequences. Senior officers are appointed for fixed terms against published targets, and evaluated on results rather than seniority.
  • Stable postings. A minimum tenure in each post, so officers are judged on outcomes and cannot be moved at will.
  • Specialists where specialism matters. Health, education, finance, engineering and technology run by people trained for them, with a route in for mid-career professionals.
  • New provinces, new services. Each new province recruits through its own public service commission, on merit, and builds its secretariat from transferred posts, not new ones.

The map and the service are linked. A new province run by the same structures, with the same incentives, will deliver the same results closer to home. That is better than distance, but it is not a reset. Our plan for the map assumes that the service is reformed alongside it.

The other side

What critics say

  • Dr Syed Akhtar Ali Shah, a former home secretary of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, argues that decades of reform announcements, portals and e-governance slogans have been mostly optics, without real change in recruitment or accountability.[5]
  • Dawn welcomed more specialisation in an earlier reform package but warned that a proposed new cadre could become yet another elite service, and said downsizing is essential.[6]

This post states Reset Pakistan’s opinion. Statements by others are summarised in our words and linked to the original reporting.