Blog · The cost
Yes, new provinces cost money. Here is how to keep the bill small
The loudest argument against new provinces is the price of more governors, ministers, secretariats and protocol. It deserves numbers, not slogans.
Critics list the bill in full: every new province needs a governor, a chief minister, a cabinet, an assembly, a High Court, a secretariat, housing, vehicles, security and pensions, locking in higher spending when Pakistan already struggles with deficits and debt.[1] Sindh’s local government minister, Syed Nasir Hussain Shah, asks whether creating a province is like building a housing society.[2] They are right that it costs money. The question is how much, and what we get for it.
What the numbers say
The most careful estimate comes from the Policy Research Institute of Market Economy (PRIME). Its October 2026 study puts the yearly cost of one new province’s core institutions at Rs 22.4 to 25.9 billion, calling this a lower bound because it leaves out buildings and duplicated police headquarters. Dividing Punjab into three would add Rs 46.9 to 56.2 billion a year, about 0.6% of the provinces’ share of federal taxes. Turning all 30 divisions into provinces would add Rs 609 to 730 billion, up to 8.6%, and 14 of those 30 provinces would spend more than a tenth of their income on administration.[3]
So the cost depends on design. Our plan, sized for both people and land, creates 15 new provincial governments. On PRIME’s figures that is Rs 336 to 389 billion a year before any savings: about 3.9 to 4.5% of the provinces’ Rs 8.64 trillion share this year,[2] or about Rs 1,600 per citizen per year. That is about half the cost of making every division a province. It is our arithmetic, set out in full in the plan.
The waste is in discipline, not in the number of provinces
Pakistan does not need new provinces to overspend. Before the 18th Amendment’s cap took effect, more than 50 of Balochistan’s 65 legislators sat in its cabinet.[4] Under Chief Minister Ali Amin Gandapur, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa assembled a 33-member cabinet, including 12 special assistants, more than a fifth of its assembly.[5] The cap shows that limits can be written into the Constitution; Khyber Pakhtunkhwa shows they must cover advisers and special assistants too.[6] The same discipline can be built into new provinces from day one:
- Cabinets capped at 11% of the assembly, without today’s 15-member floor and counting advisers and special assistants: about 115 ministers in 20 provinces, against roughly 90 four provinces may have now and the 300 that today’s floor would allow.[6][7]
- Small provinces share a High Court and a Governor with a neighbour, as Punjab and Haryana share a High Court and India allows one Governor for two states.[10][11]
- No new governor’s or chief minister’s houses for ten years; new governments use existing commissioner offices and secretariat buildings.
- Posts moved from the old provincial capitals, not created; the commissioner tier abolished where a division becomes a province.
- Statutory caps on official cars, security squads and foreign travel, with costs published every quarter.
- PRIME’s 10% rule in law: no province may spend more than a tenth of its federal transfers on administration without sharing services.[3]
The status quo is not free either
Punjab already pays for half a province. In 2020 it created 385 posts for a South Punjab Secretariat, with its own additional chief secretary and police chief, and approved Rs 4 billion for secretariat buildings and residences in Multan and Bahawalpur.[8][9] Without constitutional status, those powers could later be pulled back to Lahore. The real choice is not between spending and saving. It is between paying for government that is close to people and accountable to an elected assembly, and paying for workarounds that are neither.
The other side
What critics say
- PRIME itself recommends a formal costing of every proposed province and suggests empowered local governments as an alternative where the main goal is better access to services.[3]
- PRIME’s figures exclude one-off setup costs, police forces and full secretariats, so the true bill will be higher than any estimate here.[2][3]
- Under the current award, new provinces do not bring new money: the same provincial pool is divided among more governments unless revenue sharing is renegotiated.[3]
This post states Reset Pakistan’s opinion. Statements by others are summarised in our words and linked to the original reporting.
Sources
- Pakistan Observer: Beyond four provinces, history, hopes and hazards
- Al Jazeera, 17 Nov 2026: Is Pakistan about to carve out new provinces?
- The Standard, 30 Oct 2026: New provinces could cost Pakistan up to Rs730bn annually (PRIME)
- Dawn: 18th Amendment limits cabinet size
- Geo News: KP draws flak for record-breaking 33-member cabinet with 12 special assistants
- Constitution of Pakistan, Article 130
- Dawn: 18th Amendment curtailed cabinet size, says Balochistan CM
- Dawn, 6 Jun 2020: Buzdar approves 385 posts for south Punjab secretariat
- Dawn, 19 Jul 2020: Rs4bn approved for south Punjab secretariat, GORs
- Punjab Reorganisation Act 1966, Section 29: common High Court
- Constitution of India, Article 153